top of page
Search

Why We’re All Longing for the 90s: The Psychology of Nostalgia in Midlife

  • Writer: Kelly Rowe
    Kelly Rowe
  • Apr 5
  • 3 min read

If you’ve spent any time on social media lately, you’ve probably noticed it: grainy clips of 90s celebrities, childhood TV shows, and old-school fashion — all set to the unmistakable swell of the Goo Goo Dolls’ Iris. It’s everywhere. And it’s not just a trend; it’s a cultural mood.


As a counsellor in her (*cough cough*) 40's, I’ve been struck by how strongly this wave of 90s nostalgia is resonating with people who are now in this age group. Myself and the people who grew up in that decade are currently in midlife — a developmental stage where looking back is both common and psychologically meaningful.


But nostalgia is a complex thing. It can soothe, strengthen, and connect us. But sometimes it can also trap us. So what’s going on beneath this collective longing for the past?


90s cassette tapes
When life felt rewound, not streamed. 90s nostalgia is everywhere — but what happens when looking back becomes a way of coping?

The Psychology of Nostalgia: Why the 90s Feel So Comforting Right Now

Nostalgia isn’t just remembering. It’s a psychological process that helps us regulate emotion, make sense of identity, and feel connected to others. Research in the psychology of nostalgia shows that it can:

  • Boost mood and reduce stress: Studies by Sedikides and Wildschut show that nostalgic reflection increases feelings of warmth, belonging, and emotional comfort.

  • Support identity during transitions: Midlife often brings shifts — career changes, ageing, parenting teens, caring for parents. Nostalgia helps people feel anchored to a coherent sense of self.

  • Counteract loneliness: Research from Zhou (2008) found that nostalgia can restore feelings of social connection when people feel isolated.


So why the 90s specifically?


For many, it symbolises a time before constant digital noise — pre-smartphones, pre-social media, pre-24/7 comparison culture. A time when you could disappear for a whole day without anyone expecting a reply. A time that felt simpler, even if it wasn’t. It's too easy to look back and idealise the time - and I'm guilty of it myself sometimes.


The Good: When Nostalgia Helps Us Thrive

Healthy nostalgia can be incredibly grounding. It can:

  • Reconnect people with forgotten values

  • Remind them of their resilience

  • Strengthen relationships (“Remember when…?”)

  • Offer emotional regulation during stress

  • Help people integrate past and present identities


In therapy, nostalgia can be a doorway into:

  • What someone misses

  • What they want more of

  • What they feel they’ve lost

  • What still matters to them


It can be a bridge — a way of carrying forward what was meaningful, rather than trying to recreate the past.


The Shadow Side: When Living in the Past Becomes a Problem

Nostalgia becomes unhelpful when it shifts from reflection to escape.


Clinical research suggests nostalgia can become problematic when:

  • It reinforces beliefs like “My best years are behind me”

  • It becomes a way to avoid present-day dissatisfaction

  • It idealises the past to the point that the present feels unbearable

  • It fuels comparison (“I used to be more fun / attractive / confident”)

  • It prevents someone from imagining a hopeful future


In counselling, this often shows up as:

  • Feeling stuck or stagnant

  • Difficulty making decisions

  • Avoiding current challenges

  • Grieving a past version of oneself

  • Romanticising an era that often wasn’t as simple as memory suggests


Nostalgia is soothing — but it can also become a hiding place.


Using Nostalgia in a Healthy, Grounded Way

Nostalgia becomes a resource when it helps people reconnect with what they value. Some reflective prompts that work well in therapy:

  • What did that time in your life give you that you’re missing now?

  • What qualities did you have then that still exist in you today?

  • What parts of that era can you bring into your current life?

  • What would a future version of you hope you’re building now?


This turns nostalgia into a compass, not a cage.


It helps people reclaim:

  • Playfulness

  • Creativity

  • Connection

  • Freedom

  • Identity

  • Hope


The goal isn’t to go back — it’s to understand what that time symbolised and integrate it into the present.


Why This Matters Now

We’re living through a period of rapid change, digital overwhelm, and collective fatigue. The 90s — with their slower pace and analogue charm — offer a psychological refuge.


But the real work is in asking: What are we longing for? And how can we create more of that now?




References:

  • Batcho, K. I. (2013). Nostalgia: Retreat or Support in Difficult Times? American Journal of Psychology.

  • Barrett, F. S., Grimm, K. J., Robins, R. W., Wildschut, T., Sedikides, C., & Janata, P. (2010). Music‑evoked nostalgia. Emotion.

  • Routledge, C. (2016). Nostalgia: A Psychological Resource.

  • Sedikides, C., Wildschut, T., & Baden, D. (2004–2020). Research on nostalgia, self‑continuity, and emotional regulation.

  • Zhou, X., Sedikides, C., Wildschut, T., & Gao, D. (2008). Counteracting loneliness: On the restorative function of nostalgia. Psychological Science.


Comments

bottom of page